There’s a moment many partners, friends, and family members recognise. You ask him how he’s doing and he says, “I’m fine.” And something in the way he says it makes you certain he isn’t.
What happens next is where things often go wrong. We push him to open up. We frame his silence as stubbornness, or emotional immaturity, or proof that men just don’t want to talk about their feelings. But what if that’s the wrong diagnosis entirely? What if the problem isn’t that he won’t speak; but that he genuinely doesn’t have the words?
From a young age, a lot of boys learn how to handle things but are they taught how to name those feelings. They learn how to stay steady, stay useful, stay moving. So over time, emotions don’t disappear but get translated into something else:
- irritability instead of sadness
- withdrawal instead of overwhelm
- exhaustion instead of emotional load
- “I’m fine” because there isn’t a clear alternative
And because these expressions don’t look like what we expect “struggle” to look like, they often go unnoticed; even by the person experiencing them. We don’t always see distress as distress unless it breaks something.
But most of it doesn’t break loudly. It builds quietly.
For decades, the public conversation around men’s mental health has centred on one word: silence. Break the silence. End the stigma. Encourage men to talk. And while those messages matter, they’ve consistently missed something hiding in plain sight.
Many men don’t talk about their feelings not because they’re withholding them; but because they never learned to identify them in the first place.
What does research share
There’s a name for this in psychology: normative male alexithymia. Alexithymia, from the Greek meaning “no words for emotions,” describes difficulty identifying and describing one’s own emotional states. Researcher Ronald Levant coined the “normative” version specifically for men, arguing that it’s not a neurological condition but a socialization outcome that is the predictable result of decades of conditioning.
Read more about the research
Research supports this. From early childhood, caregivers and other significant influences begin to shape boys’ emotional experiences differently from girls. Boys are often encouraged to avoid many negative emotions, particularly those that could convey potential vulnerability such as fear and sadness so that they can appear strong.
The effects are measurable and they start early. Evidence suggests boys actually start life with greater emotional reactivity and expressiveness than girls. However, they become less verbally expressive than girls at about the age of two, and less facially expressive by age six. This isn’t hardwiring. It’s learning.
Levant found that men who had been discouraged as boys from expressing their emotions or at times even punished for doing so showed the greatest deficits in identifying and expressing emotions that reflected vulnerability, like hurt, sadness, or fear. On the other hand, they had been encouraged to express aggressive emotions.
In practice, this means that by the time a man is a teenager, let alone an adult, he hasn’t just been told not to cry. He’s been systematically undertrained in the basic skill of reading his own interior world.
And you can’t express what you don’t yet have language for.
What struggle actually looks like
The consequence of this emotional language gap is that when men do struggle, the signs rarely look like what we imagine distress to look like.
We expect collapse. We watch for tears, for withdrawal, for someone saying “I’m not okay.” But male distress more often runs quietly, masked under translation.
Emotions don’t disappear but get converted:
- Sadness becomes irritability. He’s short-tempered, snapping at small things, seeming angry for no clear reason. Friends and partners often absorb this friction without recognising it as pain.
- Overwhelm becomes withdrawal. He stops calling back. He’s present at dinner but somewhere else entirely. He’s less interested in conversations that used to feel easy.
- Emotional load becomes exhaustion. He says he’s tired and he means it, because carrying unprocessed feeling is genuinely exhausting. But he doesn’t call it what it is.
- Distress becomes productivity. He works more. He runs more. He fills every hour. Men might engage in escapist behaviours like spending excessive time at work or immersing themselves in sport; anything to avoid confronting their emotions.
Clinically, this pattern has a name too: masked depression. In its early stages, male depression often manifests as irritability, anger, hostility, aggressiveness, risk-taking, and escaping behaviour. Such expressions can mask more typical symptoms of depression like sadness, crying, feelings of guilt, and changes in appetite. Only recently have we started to recognise that these types of signs and symptoms among men can be early indicators of depression.
The stakes of missing these signs are real. The majority of men showed changes in behaviour before a crisis, especially social withdrawal, irritability, and a deterioration in mental health; but these signs were little recognised by their family and friends. Men do communicate distress, but mainly indirectly. The signals are there but we’ve just been looking for the wrong ones.
He didn’t think anything was wrong.
Consider a man and let’s call him Daniel, though you might know him by a different name. He’s in his late thirties, works in project management, coaches his son’s weekend football team. On paper: he is a solid man.
Life looked normal from the outside. He was working, showing up, replying when needed, doing what he was supposed to do.
But slowly, something felt different. Not in a dramatic way but in a steady kind of change that was hard to explain. He wasn’t really sad, but found himself tired in a way sleep didn’t fix. He started finding social catch-ups boring, and more effortful than enjoyable. He quietly stopped going out or had excuses not to and also skipped many coaching sessions. He was quicker to snap at minor inconveniences and his wife noticed before he did.
When she asked how he was doing, he said “I’m fine.” And he meant it because nothing felt serious enough to name it anything else. Nothing was wrong, exactly. He was still functioning. Still showing up. The word depression didn’t enter his thinking because what he was experiencing didn’t look like depression. It looked like coping.
This is where it often gets missed. Male depression can wear the face of the “high-functioning” man who gets up every morning, goes to work, checks all the boxes and stays productive; yet inside, he feels empty, joyless, and disconnected from life. He looks like he’s okay, but he isn’t.
Daniel’s wife eventually said something different. Not “Are you okay?” but “What’s it been like for you lately?”
That small shift opened a door. Not because the question was magic, but because it made space for an honest, imprecise answer.
What the Numbers Say
Daniel’s experience is far from isolated. The data paints a consistent picture of men struggling without recognition; including self-recognition.
Nearly 1 in 5 Australian men aged 16–85 experienced a mental illness in the past year, and around 42% will experience one in their lifetime. In Australia, low mood is the most common symptom of poor mental health experienced by men, at 68%, while anxiety (64%) and sleep issues (56%) are also extremely common. About 1 in 7 will experience depression, and 1 in 5 will experience anxiety.
Yet only around a quarter of men say they would seek professional help for emotional or mental health concerns, and many report they would be unlikely to seek help from anyone at all. Men account for around 75% of suicides in Australia, with suicide remaining the leading cause of death for males aged 15–44.
The treatment gap is not due to ignorance. It’s not that men don’t know about depression or anxiety. It’s that many don’t recognise what they’re experiencing as something that qualifies for support. The distress simply doesn’t look the way they’ve been taught distress is supposed to look.
In India, the picture carries its own weight.
According to the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), 1 in 7 Indians is affected by mental health issues. Depression impacts an estimated 45.7 million people, while anxiety disorders affect another 44.9 million.
Men’s mental health, however, remains largely underreported and less frequently diagnosed — even as the outcomes are severe. Men account for nearly 66% of suicides in India. In 2021, over 73,900 more men than women died by suicide, according to the National Crime Records Bureau. The highest rates are seen among men aged 18–59, with sharp increases among daily wage earners and high risk also seen in unemployed men.
These figures make a striking paradox visible: research indicates that women in India have a higher prevalence of mental disorders such as anxiety and depression; yet men die by suicide at far higher rates. Men are less likely to be diagnosed with depression, but more likely to die by it. Something is falling through the cracks. And that something, in large part, is the inability to recognise the symptoms.
What actually helps (in real, everyday life)
Small things that build emotional grounding again could be something such as:
- Say one honest sentence instead of “I’m fine.” It doesn’t have to be profound. “I’m a bit flat today” or “I’ve had a lot on my mind” is enough. The practice is in allowing some truth to surface, even briefly.
- Name one feeling a day. Not a diagnosis. Just a word. Tired. Restless. Heavy. Relieved. Even imprecise naming builds the habit of checking in with your own inner state.
- Take five minutes with no input. No phone, no podcast, no background noise. This isn’t meditation — it’s just noticing. What’s present right now? Where is the tension sitting in your body?
- Walk without a goal. Movement without productivity can quiet the internal noise in ways that goal-oriented exercise often doesn’t. The body processes what the mind hasn’t yet put into words.
- Walk without a goal. Movement without productivity can quiet the internal noise in ways that goal-oriented exercise often doesn’t. The body processes what the mind hasn’t yet put into words.
- Check in with the body. When emotions don’t have names yet, the body usually has clues. Tight chest. Jaw clenched. Shoulders up near the ears. These are the body’s vocabulary when the mind’s runs out.
- Replace pressure with curiosity. Instead of “What’s wrong with me?” try “What do I actually need right now?” The shift from judgment to inquiry changes the quality of what comes up.
These aren’t solutions but entry points and ways back into awareness for someone who’s been running on override for a long time.
How support can actually look (for friends, partners, families)
One of the most important things to understand about supporting the men in your life is that the goal is not to turn them into someone who processes emotions differently. It’s to create the conditions under which they might be able to access what’s already there.
That means:
- Ask differently. “What’s it been like for you lately?” invites more than “Are you okay?” The latter has one socially acceptable answer. The former opens a space.
- Sit in the ambiguity. If he says “I don’t know” or “I’m just tired” remember that’s not a wall but might be the beginning of something. Don’t rush to fill the silence or reframe it. Let it breathe.
- Don’t make it a project. Men who feel like they’ve become a concern, a problem to be solved, or someone who needs to be fixed, often retreat further. Curiosity is less threatening than intervention.
- Notice the body language signals. Changed sleep, appetite shifts, more alcohol, more time alone, less laughter are the indirect signals. You don’t need to name them as depression. You just need to stay close and notice.
- Offer rest without conditions. Not rest as reward for being productive. Just: you don’t have to earn a break.
If we speak their language and engage men in a non-threatening way around mental health, we will be much more effective. The framing matters enormously. Strength-based language like “it takes courage to look at this” lands differently than deficit-based language like “you’re not handling things well.”
The real conversation we need to have
The push to get men to open up has been well-intentioned. But it’s incomplete.
We’ve asked men to speak without giving them the vocabulary. We’ve created campaigns about breaking the silence while leaving intact the conditions that produced the silence; a boyhood that systematically trained emotion out of them, a culture that rewarded stoicism and punished vulnerability, a language of mental health that was built around female presentations of distress and doesn’t always fit what men experience.
The men who are struggling most are often not the ones staring into the void and refusing help. They’re the ones showing up every day, doing what’s needed, carrying more than they’ve named, and genuinely not recognising their own distress because it doesn’t look like distress is supposed to look.
They need something more than an invitation to talk. They need a context in which they can discover, perhaps for the first time, that what they’ve been calling fine has a more precise name and that the more precise name comes with a path forward.
That starts with a different kind of question.
Not “Are you okay?”
But “What’s it actually been like for you lately?
If you or someone you know is struggling, please contact:
Australia – Beyond Blue: 1300 22 4636 | Lifeline: 13 11 14
India – iCall: 9152987821 | Vandrevala Foundation: 1860-2662-345 (24/7)
Leave a Reply